Wasn’t the OT canon determined at the Council of Jamnia in AD 90?

After the destruction of the Temple in AD 70, Jewish religious leaders relocated to a town on the Judean coast called Jamnia (a.k.a. Yavneh). In 1871, H.H. Graetz (a Jewish writer) propounded the theory that the Jewish canon was officially closed by these rabbis at Jamnia in AD 90.[1] Following in his footsteps, critical scholars like H.E. Ryle,[2] Otto Eissfeldt,[3] Georg Fohrer,[4] and Stephen Harris[5] and claim that the OT was finally canonized in AD 90 at the Council of Jamnia.

H.E. Ryle writes, “Now we happen to know that a council of Jewish rabbis was held at Jamnia (Jabne) not very far from Jaffa, around the year 90 AD, and again, perhaps, in 118 AD…. The suggestion has been made, that we have in the Synod of Jamnia the official occasion, on which the limits of the Hebrew Canon were finally determined by Jewish authorities. It may, indeed, very well have happened at this… gathering about that time.”[6]

Who met at Jamnia?                    

After the destruction of the Temple in AD 70, many prestigious rabbis (such as Johanan ben Zakkai and Rabbi Akiba) met at Jamnia (modern day Yabneh). The Sanhedrin met there together as well.[7] The records of their teachings come from the Mishnah (AD 200).

There were two schools that met in Jamnia: (1) Beth ha-Midrash and (2) Beth Din. Beth ha-Midrash was a teaching school, and it met daily for “for the purpose of training the next generation of rabbis.”[8] Beth Din was a Sanhedrinist court that met far less frequently—perhaps annually—for the purpose of keeping the calendar and festivals uniform during a time of national and religious chaos.[9] Neither school gave decrees that had far-reaching consequences.

Did these rabbis give an official decree that canonized the Hebrew Bible?

Even though the story about a council at Jamnia is widely repeated in college textbooks about the Bible, the truth is, there is no evidence to support that a council was ever convened! The Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church explains,

The suggestion that a particular synod of Jamnia, held c. 100 AD, finally settled the limits of the OT Canon, was made by H.E. Ryle; though it has had wide currency, there is no evidence to support it.[10]

Rabbis held gather at Jamnia over a long period of time to discuss many things, but to call this a “council” is really a misnomer. Critical scholars read a “religious council” into this meeting. However, many meetings were held at Jamnia, and these were certainly not a “council” in the sense people think of church councils. The concept of a Jamnia Council has suffered from a “complete refutation”[11] from scholars like J.P. Lewis and S.Z. Leiman.[12]

Refutation of the Council of Jamnia

Rabbis didn’t use the word “canon,” which was a Christian term. Instead, they referred to “Scripture” or “books which defile the hands” to describe inspired texts.[13]

First, the Mishnah recorded debates at Jamnia over several centuries. In fact, the date of many of these rabbinical citations come from before AD 70, as well as centuries after AD 70. Newman writes, “It appears that there was at least one discussion regarding canon, involving two groups, Beth Shammai and Beth Hillel, and one named individual, Hananiah ben Hezekiah, which gives every indication of having occurred before the fall of Jerusalem in A.D. 70.”[14] Moreover, two debates occurred at Jamnia in the third and fourth centuries AD.[15]

Second, the rabbis consistently affirmed the age and authorship of the books, but debated their contents.[16] The discussions were over their contents.

Third, no official decree was ever handed down. Instead, the rabbis debated five books of the Hebrew Bible—namely, Ecclesiastes, Song of Songs, Proverbs, Ezekiel, and Esther. Geisler and Nix write, “The discussion was confined to the question whether Ecclesiastes and the Song of Songs (or possibly Ecclesiastes alone) make the hands unclean. i.e. are divinely inspired… The decision reached was not regarded as authoritative, since contrary opinions continued to be expressed throughout the second century.”[17]

Fourth, the rabbis had no debate about whether to add any books to the canon, but whether to subtract certain books. Put simply, other books were “not under consideration for canonization.”[18] The issue was whether or not to take existing books out, rather than putting new books in. Beckwith states that the main reasons for challenging these five books was due to (1) their apparent secular nature or (2) the presence of apparent contradictions.[19]

(1) Ecclesiastes was considered too SKEPTICAL. It was discussed the most,[20] and it was the only book officially charged with being heretical.[21] Some rabbis argued that the book disregarded God’s Law for life. It was later held that this could be harmonized if the author is only considering below the sun—not above the sun (i.e. heaven or God’s perspective). Rabbis also argued that it opened and ended affirming the words of the Torah, which showed its agreement with the Torah.[22]

The rabbis wanted to “to store away the book of Ecclesiastes, because they found words in it which tend to heresy.”[23] Rabbis debated this: “The Song of Songs makes the hands unclean [i.e. inspired] because it was spoken in the Holy Spirit. Ecclesiastes does not make the hands unclean [i.e. uninspired] because it is [merely] Solomon’s wisdom.”[24] (For further reading on the canonicity of Ecclesiastes, see “Introduction to Ecclesiastes”).

(2) Song of Songs was considered too SEXY. Rabbis questioned because of its erotic content.[25] The rabbis wrote, “He who, at a banquet, renders the Song of Songs in a sing-song way, turning it into a common ditty, has no share in the world to come.”[26] This book was quoted at banquets and sung at secular events.[27] (For further reading on the canonicity of Song of Songs, see “Introduction to Song of Songs”).

(3) Proverbs was considered SELF-CONTRADICTORY. Rabbis questioned because it contained apparent contradictions.[28] Specifically, Proverbs 26:4-5 was quoted.[29] (For further reading on the canonicity of Proverbs, see “Introduction to Proverbs”).

(4) Ezekiel was considered SEPARATE from Moses and the Law. The rabbis thought that Ezekiel contradicted the Torah, and the rabbis had difficulty reconciling the Temple of Ezekiel 40-48 with the former Temple.[30] Rabbis questioned the inspiration of this book because “its words contradicted the words of the Law.”[31] Specifically, the rabbis had difficulty harmonizing Ezekiel’s vision of the third Temple with the second Temple. (For further reading on the canonicity of Ezekiel, see “Introduction to Ezekiel”).

(5) Esther was considered too SECULAR. The rabbis questioned Esther because the book doesn’t contain God’s name,[32] and the protagonist marries a Gentile king.[33] Furthermore, Esther created a post-Moses annual festival.[34] (For further reading on the canonicity of Esther, see “Introduction to Esther”).

Conclusion

The rabbis eventually did affirm all of these books as canonical. Yet in addition, Beckwith makes an astute observation: “If the books had not been canonical, why should the rabbis have bothered to point out contradictions in them, since in uninspired books such contradictions were not surprising?”[35] He also writes, “Thus, there is sufficient evidence, both indirect and (in most cases) direct, to show that the five disputed books of the Hebrew Bible were canonical from a much earlier date than has been supposed. The disputes were of limited significance. In most cases they only arose after the recognition of the books as canonical, and they did not seriously interfere with that recognition, which survived the challenge and has continued as before.”[36]

Further Reading

Robert C. Newman, “The Council of Jamnia and the Old Testament Canon.” Westminster Theological Journal, 38.4 (Spr. 1976) 319-348.

Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), pp.276ff.


[1] Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 4.

[2] Herbert Edward Ryle, The Canon of the Old Testament (Harvard University, 1892), pp.182-183.

[3] Otto Eissfeldt, The Old Testament (New York: Harper and Row, 1965), p.565.

[4] Georg Fohrer, Introduction to the Old Testament (Nashville: Abingdon Press, 1968), p.486.

[5] Stephen Harris, Understanding the Bible (Palo Alto, California: Mayfield Publishing Company 1985), p.10.

[6] Herbert Edward Ryle, The Canon of the Old Testament (Harvard University, 1892), pp.182-183.

[7] Tos., Sanh. 8.1.

[8] Robert C. Newman, “The Council of Jamnia and the Old Testament Canon.” Westminster Theological Journal, 38.4 (Spr. 1976) 335-336.

[9] Robert C. Newman, “The Council of Jamnia and the Old Testament Canon.” Westminster Theological Journal, 38.4 (Spr. 1976) 335-336.

[10] F.L. Cross & E.A. Livingstone, eds., The Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church, Second Edition (Oxford, Great Britain: Oxford University Press, 1985) p. 726.

[11] Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 276.

[12] See Jamnia Revisited, by Jack P. Lewis in Lee Martin McDonald & James A. Sanders, eds., The Canon Debate, (Peabody, Massachusetts: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc., 2002) pp. 146-162.

[13] Robert C. Newman, “The Council of Jamnia and the Old Testament Canon.” Westminster Theological Journal, 38.4 (Spr. 1976) 337-338.

[14] Robert C. Newman, “The Council of Jamnia and the Old Testament Canon.” Westminster Theological Journal, 38.4 (Spr. 1976) 342.

[15] Robert C. Newman, “The Council of Jamnia and the Old Testament Canon.” Westminster Theological Journal, 38.4 (Spr. 1976) 343.

[16] Robert C. Newman, “The Council of Jamnia and the Old Testament Canon.” Westminster Theological Journal, 38.4 (Spr. 1976) 344.

[17] Norman Geisler and William Nix, A General Introduction to the Bible: Revised and Expanded (Chicago, IL. Moody Press, 1986), pp.238-240.

[18] Robert C. Newman, “The Council of Jamnia and the Old Testament Canon.” Westminster Theological Journal, 38.4 (Spr. 1976) 337.

[19] Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 2283-284.

[20] M, Eduy. 5.3, Yad. 3.5; BT, Shabb. 30, Meg. 7a; MR, Lev. 28.1, Eccli. 1.3.1, Song 1.1.11.

[21] MR, Lev. 28.1, Eccl. 1.3.1.

[22] BT, Shabb. 30b.

[23] Pesikta of Rab Kahana 68b; Leviticus Rabbah 28.1. Cited in Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 287.

[24] Tos. Yadaim 2.14. Cited in Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 284.

[25] M, Yad. 3.5; BT, Meg. 7a; MR, Song 1.1.11.

[26] Tos., Sanh. 12.10.

[27] Tos. Sanhedrin 12.10; Bab. Sanhedrin 101a.

[28] Bab. Shabbath 30b. Cited in Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 284.

[29] BT, Shabb. 30b.

[30] BT, Shabb. 13b.

[31] Bab. Shabbath 13b. Cited in Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 284.

[32] Robert C. Newman, “The Council of Jamnia and the Old Testament Canon.” Westminster Theological Journal, 38.4 (Spr. 1976) 340.

[33] Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 288.

[34] BT, Meg. 7a.

[35] Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 286.

[36] Roger T. Beckwith, The Old Testament Canon of the New Testament Church and Its Background in Early Judaism (Grand Rapids, MI: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 1986), 323.

About The Author
James Rochford

James earned a Master’s degree in Theological Studies from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, graduating magna cum laude. He is the founder of Evidence Unseen and the author of several books. James enjoys serving as a pastor at Dwell Community Church in Columbus, Ohio, where he lives with his wife and their two sons.

Join Now

You make Evidence Unseen possible. If our content has impacted you and you value our work, learn about becoming a member. Membership gives you access to our Bible commentaries, audio library, and online courses. We couldn’t do this without you. Thank you for being part of this work.

I'd like more resources.